defdes!
Trash fire? Is that what I smelled??!! My apologies for not logging in on your query sooner .. but .. I play pretty much full time with a Frank Sinatra Show, and the summer season is when it cranks! Thus, it can be difficult to grab the time needed to flesh out a detailed reply/answer. With that said, let me also mention that it is almost always BEST to seek this type of information privately, rather than on any manner of public platforms/forums .. simply because .. and I mean NO DISRESPECT to anyone here!, you tend to get a lot of "armchair quarterbacks" , and whereas they all mean well!, it just further clouds what you are trying to make clearer ... if you know what I mean. So ...
... I have been contacted on your drums privately!, and I have authenticated a few of BR's sets for him in the past. They ALL turned out to be authentic! I gotta say one of them was Buddy's Fibes set, and being a Rogers and Fibes BR guy myself .. well .. that one was fun! I also did one of Buddy's WFL sets from his Harry James days, and that one was really neat too I gotta say ... and it was indeed, authentic. I will tell you this now though, after looking at your pics: Buddy certainly DID play a set of Slingerland's with the early gold/black Slingerland badge, as well as a few of his snare drums ... they also had that badge. And yes, I have pics in my personal collection. By the way, regarding the snare drum: The Ludwig snare you have with the set was NOT a snare drum Buddy ever used while with Slingerland. Don't know how that got thrown in with the mix, but it did. Otherwise ... clear interiors are another MAJOR indicator, and ... the moved ride cymbal mount on the bass drum is also ... CORRECT! Slingerland "usually" did NOT move those mounts for him ... it was done after the fact, and because of that "could be" a bit gnarly in the drilling. Anyway ...
... should you like to discuss this set in more detail, please contact me privately. You can send me a PM through the VDF message system, and/or my regular email, which is shown on this site. I'm going to lock this thread down now, at least until you have more info, as again, it will help with all the well intentioned guesses and conjecture. BEST!!!
Tommyp