I don't know what's worse: Playing well and getting no response or playing poorly and being treated like a god. When the latter happens, it's hard for me to put on a happy face and fake it.
This isn't my worst gig, but it's a disaster that ended well. Battle of the bands in Columbus, Ohio, 1981 at some High Street bar across from Ohio State. This would be our first live performance as a unit. Although we were a new band, we got to play next to last, but the crowd was there to see the final band.
We started our five-song set and slowly but surely, the crowd started to get into it. In the middle of the fourth song, we're cruising along and the fans are bopping. The entire band was set up on a stage made from 12" risers. Our singer started jumping around and collapsed one of the risers. That caused my bass drum to fall into the hole. Tom and cymbal stands fell to the left and right. From the throne, it was actually cool to watch—like a slow-motion movie. The only thing left standing was the hi-hat.
Miraculously, the band kept playing, so I grabbed the hat stand, made my way through the carnage to the front of the stage and finished the song playing backbeats on it as I held it like a guitar. There was even a bit of impromptu choreography with the guitarist and bassist.
The crowd went wild and we should have quit right then. But we had a song left and a time limit, so we got the drums back together as fast as we could and finished.
We didn't win. The crowd was there to see the final band and crowd response was enough of a criterion to overrule first-place votes for us from some of the judges, who told us they knew the last band and were prepared to vote for them sight unseen until they saw us. But the judges were influential on the local scene and we were able to parlay that into some pretty good gigs over the next few years.
One of those could qualify. We were opening at a place called the Agora, which was the major 3,500-seat bar across from OSU. Our first song was "Get Off of My Cloud," in which I would walk out alone and play the opening beat as the rest of the band entered one by one. As I started the beat, the guitarist broke a string, so I'm out there bashing like an idiot for two minutes (it seemed a lot longer) while he's fixing his guitar. Once we got going, it was a pretty good show, but the guitarist bought me beers for the rest of the night.