I also posted this under Vintage Drum Forum:
I plan to bring my Zildjian's up to playing condition. In 1981, I bought all new: 21" (Large bell) Rock Ride, 14" New Beat Hi-hat set, 18" Swish, 18" Light crash, & 16" Med/Thin Suspended crash.
After very little playing time since new, these sat in storage for about 35 years. This resulted in surface haze, a little corrosion from moisture drops (green, brown, and some black spots), and old fingerprints becoming prominent on the surfaces.
I am using an old bottle of Zildjian cymbal cleaner, and have found that the Zildjian ink stampings such as "New Beat Top" will rub right off along with all the haze and other oxidation.
From paste experience I know that the final result will look like a brilliant, but slightly off-color appearance from a freshly made cymbal. So my question is that for either playing or re-selling is this "cleaned" appearance desirable, and is there any advantage in attempting to keep the original patina and stampings on a complete side of the cymbal (usually the underneath side)?