BGT!...
Hmmm... and you KNOW that you have to mention "who it was", right?! LOL! Truthfully, I would be interested to know as it's kind of hard to get one's head around the fact that a "great player and technician" would be that ridiculously stupid on purpose... if you know what I mean. Seriously...
One doesn't have to like every drummer they hear, but one SHOULD be able to recognize talent/chops even outside of one's musical comfort zone and give a nod of approval. Buddy would and should impress ANYBODY that actually knows what's what, regardless of whether or not they like him or his style of playing. Anyway!,
Thought I might attach a few pics of my LATE 1969 Slingerland COW 4X14 Buddy Rich for you to see. Amazingly, the WMP model I have is a mere few hundred digits away from this one... what were the chances?! They are both beautiful drums, but again, I also prefer the COW in the sound department. Three plies/rings, Zoomatic, StickChopper Hoops, EXACTLY like Buddy played his, and all original.
You mentioned that the drum didn't sound tinny or shrill... YES! That's the beauty of a 3 ply shell/rings with a REAL metal wrap, as opposed to a lot of "piccolo" type snare drums that are all metal/brass/etc. Amazingly, these model snares weren't all that popular back in the day.. ( outside of the Buddy fans that HAD to have what BR was playing at all times of course! LOL! ) .. thus they can be a little hard to find today, and moreso in nice condition, especially the COW model as a lot of times the wrap looks like crap. The StickChoppers also ADD to the sound of the drum as there is a difference in sound between the StickChoppers and StickSavers. Buddy always preferred StickChoppers if they were available, and with Slingerland they were! By the way,
Buddy LOVED this snare drum!... until he didn't. That was Buddy! LOL!! He did play it with better than decent regularity between LATE 1969 and early 1973 though.
Tommyp