Only Admins can see this message.
Data Transition still in progress. Some functionality may be limited until the process is complete.
Processing Attachment, Gallery - 147.50731%

My Vintage 602 Collection is growing!

Loading...

Yesterday I found an beautiful set of pre-serial 14" Formula 602 sound edge hats for the equivalent (in USD terms) of around USD 128. I just could not let them pass by. Some pics hereunder. I date them to somewhere between 1967 (when the sound edge concept started) and 1971 (when Paiste started with serial numbers). The top hat weighs 900g and the bottom 1050g. They are really, barring the normal marks and lovely patina, in as new condition with not a single nick or chip around the edges and no sign of keyholing, cracks etc. I am very stoked. And they sound amazing. I also have a 2002 set of sound edge hats and the 602's are most certainly their mature and mellow grand-dad. Crisp, dark, mellow. I love the foot chick.

So far my 602 collection consists of:

Pre-serial 14" Sound Edge Hats

Pre-Serial 20" Crash

1974 20" Crash

1974 22" Medium

Pre-serial 24" Medium

Just a question: I have never seen the stamp with the patent info on the inside of Paiste hats - does anyone know what the deal is with that?

Cheers from a wet and rainy Durban, South Africa

Erik

Drums: Ludwig / Star / Tama / Yamaha
Snares: Arai /Mapex / Ludwig / Slingerland / Star / Tama
Cymbals: Meinl / Paiste / Tosco / Wuhan /Zildjian / Zyn
Posted on 9 years ago
#1
Guest
Loading...

Nice looking 602 SE hats, Erik. Do they have a serial number or not? If you mentioned that explicitly I missed it.

I have more info about various things, but it's all subject to change as more information comes to hand. I've done a reasonable amount of research on the subject, but new information sometimes appears which changes the interpretation. Here's what I believe today:

First, serial numbers started around the third quarter of 1972. This is based on a few different lines of evidence. If it is accurate, it means that any 602s with the serial number starting 0 or 1 represent 1980 and 1981 (last of the black labels before the blue labels came on the scene). I've got a large database of 602 and Sound Creation data (3,300 cymbals and counting) which has been used to test this out by looking at the distribution of first digits. However, I last did a full analysis a few years back and I've got lots more data since then. But I haven't gone and had another look yet.

There are at least 3 distinct types of 602 stamp, and I've illustrated them here:

http://black.net.nz/paiste.html

Your SE hats seem to be the Outline version. I'm still collecting data on the association between the Outline stamp and other cymbal attributes. In a preliminary analysis the leading digits (year) for examples of the Outline Stamp include:

pre serial (but possibly black label no serial)

2

3

4

5

6

7

9

0 (judged 1980 on independent evidence so it goes at the end of the series)

But all of these years also have examples of the more common Solid Stamp. On the evidence so far the Outline Stamp may predate the Black Label era (but see below) and lasts for the entire Black Label era, although at a much lower frequency than the Solid Stamp. But it's early days for the evidence and my analysis.

Note that I usually use the shorthand way of referring to the Black Label era "as if" the black ink saying "PAISTE FORUMLA 602" coincides perfectly with the beginning of serial numbers. But it doesn't. There are some cymbals which have the black ink saying "PAISTE FORUMLA 602" below the pressed in die stamp, and also have the red ink model at 3 o'clock, but no serial number. I've got a 20" flat ride like that. SE hats are different in that the model ink at 3 o'clock is black not red. But the same principles apply. And your bottom seems like it might be one of the black ink saying "PAISTE FORUMLA 602" yet no serial number.

It may turn out that the Outline version of the stamp is mostly or always on models with the very fine lathing (flat rides and SE hats being the most common, but there are others like the Morello series, the Deep Ride and maybe other Seven Sound Set models). Alas, I only properly documented the three types a few months ago and I didn't collect the right information for the first 9 years in my database. That's because I listened to others who persuaded me that there weren't meaningful variations rather than looking for myself, plus the fact that I started my project with just price estimation in mind and not collecting as much data as possible about each cymbal. *sigh*

About the patent stamps: there is a sequence of patent stamps on the SE hats and on flat rides. The earliest ones say "Pat. Pending". I've got those on my SE hats (which are 56 ripples) and on my flat ride. That stamp dates to the time between filing and the patent being issued:

Paiste Flat Ride: United States Patent 3,546,994 Filed Jan 22, 1969 and Issue Date: December 15, 1970 (but note that flat rides appeared in the Seven Sound Set before the patent was applied for, and sometimes carry the earlier name "space sound").

Paiste Sound Edge Hats: United States Patent 3,453,923 Filed Aug 3, 1967 and Issue Date: July 8, 1969

Then as patents were granted in different countries a longer list appears in the ink stamp. I haven't even done the detailed work to pin down the actual years when the patents were granted in the different countries. But I know the more countries you have, the later the cymbal. I have collected some examples of the different length of patent country lists, pending some future attempt to tie that back to other dating details.

Which brings me back to your SE hats. If they don't have a serial number but do have several countries in the patent list, that's helpful data to add to my database. And if they have a serial number, that would be great to know as well. And your homework (as a fellow researcher of obscure topics) is to count the number of ripples. I've seen: 56, 54, 52, 42, 38 on 14" SE hats. The number of ripples seems to go down over the years as a production simplification which doesn't affect the sound quality.

And cheers back from a wet and rainy Auckland, New Zealand.

Steve

Posted on 9 years ago
#2
Loading...

Thanks Zenstat. As always, very informative. Those hats are pre -serial. As soon as I have recovered from this hangover and can see clearly, I will count the ripples. Being a New Zealander, I assume you follow the Rugby world cup - good luck against Argentina today. I cannot believe that we lost against Japan yesterday. Our rugby is in a very sad state !!! Hence my current condition 🍻🍻

Drums: Ludwig / Star / Tama / Yamaha
Snares: Arai /Mapex / Ludwig / Slingerland / Star / Tama
Cymbals: Meinl / Paiste / Tosco / Wuhan /Zildjian / Zyn
Posted on 9 years ago
#3
Guest
Loading...

Yes the shock Bok loss to Japan is big news here. You definitely don't want to try counting ripples until you are feeling better! :p

Posted on 9 years ago
#4
Loading...

I can imagine. Here's our Sunday paper headline this morning.

OK, so a headache tab and cup of coffee later and I counted the ripples - there are 40. This this appears to be a new specimen - a **** naledi, so to speak :-)

1 attachments
Drums: Ludwig / Star / Tama / Yamaha
Snares: Arai /Mapex / Ludwig / Slingerland / Star / Tama
Cymbals: Meinl / Paiste / Tosco / Wuhan /Zildjian / Zyn
Posted on 9 years ago
#5
Guest
Loading...

So I had a chance to check through my reference gallery and this is the same patent list as yours have (also on a pre serial pair but dated to early 1972 on other grounds)

[img]http://black.net.nz/paiste/images/patents-SE-preserial.png[/img]

The pair of 15" hats in the above photo also has the outline version of the 602 stamp.

By 1978 the list had the "Other Countries Pending" removed by the look of things:

[img]http://black.net.nz/paiste/images/patents-SE-1978.jpg[/img]

It may be that Sound Edge patents were not sought in further countries after all.

Posted on 9 years ago
#6
Posts: 1345 Threads: 173
Loading...

From Black Label

Thanks Zenstat. As always, very informative. Those hats are pre -serial. As soon as I have recovered from this hangover and can see clearly, I will count the ripples. Being a New Zealander, I assume you follow the Rugby world cup - good luck against Argentina today. I cannot believe that we lost against Japan yesterday. Our rugby is in a very sad state !!! Hence my current condition 🍻🍻

Japan got well and truly beaten today by the Scottish. I'm Irish, but don't follow the Rugby, we do OK in the 6 Nations, but NZ usually destroys all teams in the world.

Nice cymbals, can I ask if you got them from EU?

Posted on 9 years ago
#7
Loading...

From Chromeo

Japan got well and truly beaten today by the Scottish. I'm Irish, but don't follow the Rugby, we do OK in the 6 Nations, but NZ usually destroys all teams in the world. Nice cymbals, can I ask if you got them from EU?

Yeah, but Japan did look strong in the first half. W have a mammoth task up ahead of us against Samoa on Saturday!

I purchased all those cymbals locally in SA.

Here's a little video I made where you can hear the 22 an 24" 602.

[ame="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bE0mFIw5j-I"]22 & 24" Paiste Ride Comparison - YouTube[/ame]

Drums: Ludwig / Star / Tama / Yamaha
Snares: Arai /Mapex / Ludwig / Slingerland / Star / Tama
Cymbals: Meinl / Paiste / Tosco / Wuhan /Zildjian / Zyn
Posted on 9 years ago
#8
Loading...

so far it looks like are 3 different patent stamps with the early SE hats

1) pat. pending - this will be found on the very early models made in or closer to 1967

2) 4 country stamp - this came out sometime ~ 69-70

3) six country stamp - not sure when they started using this one, closer to 1972 but possibly as far back as mid-1970

The "Other Countries Pending" text is removed from the 6-country stamp starting in 1976

Posted on 5 years ago
#9
  • Share
  • Report
Action Another action Something else here