Only Admins can see this message.
Data Transition still in progress. Some functionality may be limited until the process is complete.
Processing Attachment, Gallery - 144.30063%

Need help dating K Istanbul cymbals

Loading...

Hello, I have been fortunate to own and play some wonderful old K Zildjian cymbals for many years. I have never tried to identify them but have lately been asked by other drummers how old they were. My supportive wife showed me how to use her kitchen scale to weigh them. I have a 21 and a half inch Istanbul ride that weighs 2,225 grams, a pair of 15 inch high hats (844 and 932 grams) and two older Constantinople cymbals (15 inch 1,372 grams), and 16 inch (1,575 grams). The two older cymbals appear to have the same stamp to me. I have labeled the photos with diameter and grams. Could someone who knows a lot more about these than me please let me know if the photos are decent enough to estimate a type/date? Sorry that I could not focus the little digital camera any better than this. I play these cymbals on either a little home made Be Bop set or an old Dixieland style vintage set. They are a lot of fun and blend well with newer cymbals. Thanks in advance, Joe

Posted on 3 years ago
#1
Posts: 85 Threads: 25
Loading...

First and second pictures: Intermediate Stamp, made between 1959 and 1966.

Third and last picture: Zildjian K Constantinople made between 1900 and 1910's/20's?

Fourth picture: New Stamp, made between 1967 and 1977.

60s Gretsch RB 20/12/14 Burgundy Sparkle
60s Gretsch RB 18/12/14 Silver Glitter
60s Gretsch RB bass drum 16x12 Silver Glitter
60s Gretsch RB COB 4160
60s Rogers Holiday 14x5'5 in Steel Gray Ripple
50s Gretsch RB 14x5'5 MBP
39/41 Gretsch Gladstone 3-Way Tension 14x6'5 Dark Mahogany finish
38/42 Slingerland RK 14x6'5 Sparkling Green.
1936 Leedy Broadway Standard 14x5 WMP
Old Zildjian K's
Posted on 3 years ago
#2
Loading...

Jmoll, Thanks so much. I don't remember where or when I bought the ride cymbal, but I have had it since the late 1970's. I had switched from playing rock and country to "society" combo music and jazz. It also works well for Latin tunes, but I have other cymbals with a louder bell sound for Latin (Matt Nolan ride). The high hats and two old K Constantinople hand cymbals were gifted to me. The hand cymbals work well when paired with modern Sabian hand hammered cymbals for orchestra work because they provide a lower and mid range to the newer hand cymbals. I usually keep the straps off of them and use them on Dixieland type sets where they are just an effect. My ears have really gotten use to the sound of old K's and I enjoy playing them in jazz jams. Thanks again, I really appreciate it.

Posted on 3 years ago
#3
Posts: 891 Threads: 26
Loading...

yep

pic 1,2 Intermediate

pic 4 New Stamp

.................................................. ......Joe
Posted on 3 years ago
#4
Loading...

JDA and JMOLL, Thanks gentlemen, I really appreciate it. I also have an 18" with a chunk missing that was drilled out for larger than normal rivets. There is no stamp visible, it may be part of the missing chunk. I put three of those large brass rivets designed to hold notebook pages together (old technology there) from an office supply company in the cymbal and it sounds pretty good as a sizzle. It screams Istanbul K to me due to sound, hammering, bell, profile and so forth. It came from the two wonderful gentlemen at Olympic Drums and Percussion and I wanted to mention them as a great source for vintage drums and hardware and also cymbals. They might be overlooked as only a source for concert percussion but are definitely worth checking out.

Posted on 3 years ago
#5
Posts: 891 Threads: 26
Loading...

From Pedal_Pusher

JDA and JMOLL, Thanks gentlemen, I really appreciate it. I also have an 18" with a chunk missing that was drilled out for larger than normal rivets. There is no stamp visible, it may be part of the missing chunk. I put three of those large brass rivets designed to hold notebook pages together (old technology there) from an office supply company in the cymbal and it sounds pretty good as a sizzle. It screams Istanbul K to me due to sound, hammering, bell, profile and so forth. It came from the two wonderful gentlemen at Olympic Drums and Percussion and I wanted to mention them as a great source for vintage drums and hardware and also cymbals. They might be overlooked as only a source for concert percussion but are definitely worth checking out.

Show a picture we may be able to tell Era- from visual of the rest of the cymbal

.................................................. ......Joe
Posted on 3 years ago
#6
Loading...

JDA, You shamed me into actually taking some photos. Sorry for the quality, I have no flat surfaces in the drum room. I owe some sound files to various folks. Can I post audio files made with a Zoom recorder? If not, I can ask my long suffering wife to make a video on her cell phone. Here are five shots of the 17 and a half or so diameter cymbal. I nicknamed it "Chunky" and it does not seem to mind. I did not weigh it when I did the others. It only cost $100 from Olympia Drums and Percussion. I love playing the sides of the chunk with a bass bow (Pop's rosin is the best) or stick or one handed brush strand mandolin rolls. When I played in the local orchestra we had a pair of 22" (I think) ancient K's that belonged to Fred Hinger. His son Bill played them once in a while when the music was especially pompous and he had the physical strength to hold them. They weighed a ton but sounded heavenly for some crashes. After one concert a very nice and well meaning gentleman offered to buy the symphony some new crash cymbals so we would not have to use the old broken ones. Bill's father bought them from a former vaudeville theater drummer and they had been stepped on somewhere along the way while he owned them. They still sounded amazing. Thanks for the interest and information!

Posted on 3 years ago
#7
Posts: 891 Threads: 26
Loading...

not sure which era it is But I like it/thanks/

.................................................. ......Joe
Posted on 3 years ago
#8
Loading...

You are quite welcome. It actually sounds good and is pretty versatile for drum set or as a suspended cymbal for band/orchestra (minus the rivets). Were factory rivet holes larger in the past? I assume it is from the "unlucky era" whenever that was...

Here is the text from the Olympia Drums and Percussion web site: "Here is one of the best sounding and ugliest cymbals we have ever found. We don't normally list cymbals with this much damage to the plate but this cymbal sounds so good that we want to find it a new home. There is no stamp on the cymbal. It must have been cut out with the edge repair. We attribute it to K. Zildjian based on the bell shape, hammer marks, and tonal quality. It has a beautiful, warm, even distribution of overtones that will sound beautiful as a suspended cymbal in an orchestra or concert band. There is some keyholing along with the extra holes and edge repair. This is a great opportunity to own a fine old cymbal at a steal of a price. The person that rescues this cymbal and puts it back to work won't be sorry."

Posted on 3 years ago
#9
  • Share
  • Report
Action Another action Something else here