Only Admins can see this message.
Data Transition still in progress. Some functionality may be limited until the process is complete.
Processing Attachment, Gallery - 128.86013%

Is the piano a "drum" or a stringed instrument?

Posts: 5173 Threads: 188
Loading...

I happened to catch this program on PBS the other night. It was SO good, I couldn't take my eyes off of it. The piano is a really, really, REALLY complicated percussion instrument that hits strings instead of heads.

I will only load the first part, here, but the program is in 10 parts so you'll have to click on the other segments.

The craftsmanship that it takes to make a fine instrument like a concert grand piano is really mind-boggling!

As musicians and as people who appreciate a well-made musical instrument, I think we can all relate!

Check it out:

Pt.1

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZneYtZybZ0[/ame]

"God is dead." -Nietzsche

"Nietzsche is dead." -God
Posted on 14 years ago
#1
Loading...

The piano is classified as a "string" AND "percussion" instrument. It seems weird, though, since you don't fret the notes or strike it...

1970 Ludwig Downbeat
1965 Ludwig Hollywood
1970 Ludwig Jazzette
Posted on 14 years ago
#2
Posts: 3972 Threads: 180
Loading...

I don't fret the notes either. I just let 'em flow where they may.

Posted on 14 years ago
#3
Loading...

From mcjnic

I don't fret the notes either. I just let 'em flow where they may.

Ba-dum-CH!!!

1970 Ludwig Downbeat
1965 Ludwig Hollywood
1970 Ludwig Jazzette
Posted on 14 years ago
#4
Loading...

Hmm......I've always classified piano as "keyboards"......yes it technically is both a string instrument (as it does have strings) and a percussive instrument (the mallets do hit the strings), but I think it really should be classified in a class by itself as "keyboards" along with the organ, and harpsicord, and synthesizers such as Moog, etc.

Keyboards......think about it.....Cool Dude

Posted on 14 years ago
#5
Loading...

Hi,

Generally instruments are divided into three categories (string, wind and percussion), which of course leaves off newer developments such as synthesizers/edrums/etc. There are other classification schemes with more classes.

The Greeks had two families of instruments Animate (voice) and Inanimate. They subdivided the Inanimate into string and wind. The Arabs apparently had a similar two group classification. Later on percussion was given a classification of some sort.

Pianos were developed after the traditional three family classification, which is part of the reason for the piano's awkward inclusion in percussion. Worth noting that percussion and string have been classed as one entity in the past because of their common need for tensioning to produce the desired note.

Here is some discussion of the issues from Grove Music Online; Instruments, classification of:

"Our own present-day practice does not amount to much more. Sound-instruments are divided into three major categories: string instruments, wind instruments and percussion instruments. This cannot be defended even on the grounds that it satisfies day-to-day requirements. A large number of instruments cannot be fitted into any of the three groups without placing them in an unnatural position, like the celesta, which, as a percussion instrument, is brought into close proximity to drums and so on. As a remedy one introduces a fourth group under the disconcerting heading ‘miscellaneous’ – in any systematic grouping an admission of defeat. Moreover, the current classification is not only inadequate, but also illogical. The first requirement of a classificatory system is surely that the principle of demarcation remains the same throughout for the main categories. Our customary divisions, however, follow two different principles, string instruments being distinguished by the nature of the vibrating substance but wind and percussion by the mode of sound-excitation – ignoring the fact that there are string instruments which are blown, like the Aeolian harp, or struck, like the pianoforte. The customary subdivisions are no better. Wind instruments are divided into woodwind and brass, thus giving a subordinate criterion of differentiation, namely, material, an unjustifiable predominance and flagrantly disregarding the fact that many ‘brass’ instruments are or were once made of wood, like cornetts, serpents and bass horns, and that in any case many ‘woodwind instruments’ are optionally or invariably made of metal, as flutes, clarinets, saxophones, sarrusophones, tritonicons etc."

It's all weird and reminds me of when I puzzled over where to put my reggae records and my grade school wonderment that despite having Irish/Scottish parents, I was apparently a caucasian...

Patrick

Posted on 14 years ago
#6
  • Share
  • Report
Action Another action Something else here