Please, I'm trying to restore a Ludwig 6 1/2 incher snare drum with a Rocker P-82 throw-off ( 2 5/8 inch hole spacing). I just don't like the throw-off. To me (only an opinion), it seems difficult to fine tune. Are there any good quality alternatives out there? I've tried researching, but have come up with nothing. Thank you.
Brian
Brian,
Any thoughts on making an adaptor plate so you could mount a P85?
Cheers
I built several drums this winter and used the Indie brand throw offs. Their hole spacing is adjustable so they work as a replacement strainer without drilling more holes. I like their adjustments. Not cheap but well worth the cost.
Thanks, Rod and Pedal_Pusher for the great ideas! I'll definitely look into both suggestions today. Appreciate the input, guys!
Brian
Hi Brian!
You are correct about the P82 requiring a 2-5/8" hole spacing. However, the Inde strainer only goes to 2.5". You'd have to modify the holes in the shell to accommodate the strainer.
-Mark
Thanks, Mark, you're right. I thought so, but wasn't positive. I did a bit of googling this morning and sure enough, the INDe throw-off only extends to 2 1/2 inches. Hmm...
Brian
Why Ludwig would go with such an odd spacing is beyond me! Maybe a marketing decision to keep people from using a P83/P85/P88?
What about the P82 do you not like? Looking at pictures of this strainer, it reminds me of some Tama strainers. Maybe it's just the rubber knob and throw? It looks like a reasonable strainer to me. Maybe a new one would work better? I see them over at Drums On Sale for less than $17.
-Mark
Why Ludwig would go with such an odd spacing is beyond me! Maybe a marketing decision to keep people from using a P83/P85/P88? What about the P82 do you not like? Looking at pictures of this strainer, it reminds me of some Tama strainers. Maybe it's just the rubber knob and throw? It looks like a reasonable strainer to me. Maybe a new one would work better? I see them over at Drums On Sale for less than $17.-Mark
You are very perceptive, Mark! Rubber and plastic are not my favourite materials! I am lucky though. This strainer is devoid of these substances. I suppose I'm getting used to this throw-off. It is just not as responsive as a good old P-83 or a P-85. On the other hand, it is equipped with "mini-t-rods" that only require a standard drum key rather than the traditional screws which are awkward and easily stripped in time! Thanks again, my friend! I always take your advice to heart.
Brian
Brian,
Let us know what you decide to do about the strainer. I completely get it about just not liking it!
It's also possible that you can lengthen the upper hole with a small round file. Leave the lower hole alone. It wouldn't take too much to modify that upper hole and use either the Inde or Ludwig strainer of your choice. I'm partial to the P88, but the Inde is really nice, too!
-Mark
Brian,Let us know what you decide to do about the strainer. I completely get it about just not liking it! It's also possible that you can lengthen the upper hole with a small round file. Leave the lower hole alone. It wouldn't take too much to modify that upper hole and use either the Inde or Ludwig strainer of your choice. I'm partial to the P88, but the Inde is really nice, too!-Mark
Hey, Mark! I think I'll let things alone for the time being. I'm sure I'll get used to the strainer in time. Maybe it's just because I'm not used to it. I'm an old dog and sometimes, I need to be reminded that it is possible to learn new tricks! Thanks for everything, my friend!
Brian
