It's all subjective. What is it the buyer/player wants?
Right. I think most all of us have agreed on that point ... ad nauseum ... in about eight thousand threads.
I think it is foolish and maybe even egotistical to try to force an opinion on everyone.
Who was doing this? I reread this thread three times. I can't find this reference.
All I'm saying is the final opinion of beauty is in the eye of the buyer, not the seller. And if the buyer wants a red sparkle set that is not available original, and he's willing to pay for it, what's the problem?
Nothing. I don't believe anyone refuted that point.
It really seems to me that some "purists" are a little fanatical about it all.
That's the nature of the game. Everyone is fanatical about something in their life. This being a vintage drum forum ... some of the people are fanatical about vintage drums. Go figure.
They remind me of some Mac computer users who look down their noses at anyone who uses a PC.
I'm on a Mac. One of the lives I've led was as a Computer Systems/Network Eng. I understand that Mac/PC fight only too well. Mind Blowi
Now, shall we take a look at your original post ...
What would be the difference in the relative value vintage drum sets in (1) original pristine condition, (2) wrap in poor condition, and (3) re-wrapped and restored?
That has been addressed by quite a few of us. Agree or disagree ... several opined.
And finally, if a set were re-wrapped, which wrap would be the most popular?
That, too was addressed. It would all depend upon the original shells and the authentic wraps of the day ... or ... whatever wrap the potential buyer wanted.
Just for sake of example, a 60’s Ludwig 22” bass drum, 12” side tom, 13” side tom, 16x16 floor tom, and a 5.5x15 snare drum.
ok.
What I would like is an approximate value comparison so I can decide the best margin of profit comparing restoration with condition.
Again, it was given. There is a HUGE difference in value depending on the manufacturer and the era. You really can't generalize here.
In other words, is it worth it to acquire a drum set that needs re-wrapping and doing all the work and expense to restore it.
Again yet again, it was addressed by several. You have to define "worth" for yourself. We all place value on time and money in different ways. I assure you, my values are not yours. That's how life history works. We are all different ... and yet, very similar.
And is there a market for restored vintage drums?
Most say no. One or two say yes. You have to ultimately decide for yourself. It is your money, after all.
Good luck with your exploits. Run a restoration thread to keep us apprised.